Task 38
Climate Change Effects of Biomass and Bioenergy Systems
Joensuu, Finland 2000
Land-Use, Land-Use Change And Forestry: The Road To COP6
Task 25: Greenhouse Gas Balances of Bioenergy Systems
28 September 2000 – Joensuu, Finland
Jointly organised by
| COST E21 “Contribution of Forests and Forestry to the Mitigation of Greenhouse Effects” |
EFI European Forest Institute |
University of Joensuu Faculty of Forestry. |
Workshop Proceedings
Land-Use, Land-Use Change And Forestry: The Road To COP6
28 September 2000, Joensuu, Finland
Session 1: Overview of the IPCC Special Report
Session 2: Carbon accounting methodologies
Session 3: Land use, land-use change and forestry activities under Articles 3.3 and 3.4
Session 4: Current state of negotiations
Workshop Program
Thursday 28 September, 2000
Session 1: Overview of the IPCC Special Report
Chapter 2, Implications of different definitions and generic issues
Presented by Gert-Jan Nabuurs, ALTERRA Green World Research, the Netherlands
Chapter 3, Afforestation, Reforestation, and Deforestation (ARD) Activities
Presented by Bernhard Schlamadinger, Joanneum Research , Austria
Chapter 4, Additional human-induced activities – Article 3.4
Presented by Gregg Marland, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, USA
Chapter 5, Project based activities
Presented by Omar Masera, University of Mexico, Mexico
Chapter 6, Implications of the Kyoto Protocol for the reporting guidelines
Presented by Justin Ford-Robertson, Forest Research, New-Zealand
Session 2: Carbon accounting methodologie
Effectiveness of LULUCF carbon accounting methodologies in supporting climate-conscious policy measures
Robert Matthews1 and Rebecca Heaton2
1Forestry Commission Research Agency, Wrecclesham, U.K.
2The Salix Project, University of South Wales, UK
The ton-year index as a basis for carbon accounting of forestation projects under the Climate Convention
Kim Pingoud
VTT Energy, Finland
Presentation Video
A practical procedure of accounting for LUCF activities under the Kyoto Protocol
Miko Kirschbaum et. al.
CSIRO Forestry and Forest Products, Australia
Presented by Annette Cowie
State Forests New South Wales, Australia
Presentation Video
Carbon accounting methodologies – a comparison of real-time, tonne years and one-off stock change approaches
Piers Maclaren and Justin Ford-Robertson
Forest Research, New Zealand
Presentation Slides
Presentation Video
Session 3: Land use, land-use change and forestry activities under Articles 3.3 and 3.4
Trees as C sinks and sources in the EU in light of Kyoto Protocol Article 3.3 and the ongoing negotiations
Jari Liski et al
European Forest Institute
Presented by Timo Karjalainen
Domestic Options for Carbon Management
Doug Bradley
Domtar Inc, Ottawa, Canada
Presentation Video
Adressing COP6 decisions on agricultural soil carbon accumulation
Susan Subak
Environmental Protection Agency, U.S.A.
Presentation Video
Measuring and marketing of C sequestration in planted forests in New South Wales, Australia
Annette Cowie and Keith Lamb
State Forests New South Wales, Australia
Presentation Video
Bernhard Schlamadinger presented an overview of a paper by Kevin Gurney and Jason Neff,
Carbon Sequestration Potential in Canada, Russia and the United States Under Article 3.4 of the Kyoto Protocol.
This paper can be downloaded here.
Session 4: Current state of negotiations
Status of the negotiations on LULUCF
Heikki Granholm
Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry, Finland
To agree or not to agree: perspectives for LULUCF negotiations
Andreas Fischlin
ETH Zurich, Switzerland
Sinks and the CDM: status of negotiations and the outlook to COP6
Lorenzo Ciccarese1 and Davide Pettenella2
1National Environment Protection Agency, Italy
2University of Padova, Italy
List of Participants
| Name | Institution | Address | Phone | Fax | |
| ALHOJÄRVI, Pekka | World Bank | 1818 H. Street, NW Washington, D.C. 20433 USA | +1 202 458 7433 | +1 202 522 1142 | palhojarvi@worldbank.org |
| BARITZ, Rainer | State Forest Research Station Baden-Württenberg | Wonnhalderstrasse 4, 79100 Freiburg, GERMANY | +49 761 4018 117 | +49 761 4018 333 | baritz@fva.bwl.de |
| BRADLEY, Doug | Domtar Inc. | 1600 Scott Street, Ottawa, Ontario K1Y 4N7, CANADA | +1 613 725 6854 | +1 613 725 6820 | doug.bradley@domtar.com |
| BUGMANN, Harald | Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, Mountain Forest Ecology | ETH-Zentrum, 8092 Zürich, SWITZERLAND | +41 1 632 3239 | +41 1 632 1146 | bugmann@fowi.ethz.ch |
| BYRNE, Kenneth | University College Dublin, Dept. Envir. Resource Mngt, Forest Ecosys. Res. Gr. | Belfield, Dublin 4, IRELAND | +353 1 706 7673 | +353 1 706 1102 | kenneth.byrne@ucd.ie |
| CICCARESE, Lorenzo | Italian Environment Protection Agency, Dept. of Natural and Protected Areas | Via V.Brancati 48, 00144 Rome, ITALY | +39 06 5007 2618 | +39 06 5007 2649 | ciccarese@anpa.it |
| COWIE, Annette | State Forest of New South Wales | P.O.Box 100 Beecroft, 2121 Sydney, AUSTRALIA | +61 29872 0138 | +61 29871 6941 | annettec@sf.nsw.gov.au |
| DALEN, Lars | Norwegian Forest Research Institute | Hogskoleveien 12, 1432 Ås, NORWAY | +47 649 49000 | +47 649 42980 | Lars.Dalen@nisk.no |
| EGGERS, Thies | European Forest Institute | Torikatu 34, 80100 Joensuu, FINLAND | +358 13 252 020 | +358 13 124 397 | thies.eggers@efi.fi |
| ERIKSSON, Hillevi M. | The National Board of Forestry | 55183 Jönköping, SWEDEN | +46 36 15 5560 | Hillevi.Eriksson@svo.se | |
| FARRELL, Edward P. | University College Dublin, Faculty of Agriculture | Belfield, Dublin 4, IRELAND | +353 1 706 7716 | +353 1 706 1102 | ted.farrell@ucd.ie |
| FINÉR, Leena | Finnish Forest Research Institute, Joensuu Research Station | P.O. Box 68, 80101 Joensuu, FINLAND | +358 13 251 4040 | +358 13 251 4111 | leena.finer@metla.fi |
| FISCHLIN, Andreas | Swiss Federal Inst. of Technology Zurich, Terrestrial Systems Ecology | Grabenstrasse 3, 8952 Schlieren/Zurich, SWITZERLAND | +41 1 633 6090 | +41 1 633 1123 | andreas.fischlin@ ito.umnw.ethz.ch |
| FORD-ROBERTSON, Justin | Forest Research | Private Bag 3020 / Sala St., Rotorua, NEW ZEALAND | +67 7 347 5661 | +67 7 347 5332 | jfr@forestresearch.co.nz |
| FORSS, Eero | University of Joensuu, Faculty of Forestry | P.O.Box 111, 80101 Joensuu, FINLAND | +358 13 251 3629 | +358 13 251 3590 | eero.forss@joensuu.fi |
| FRÜHWALD, Arno | University of Hamburg | Leuschnerstrasse 91, 21031 Hamburg, GERMANY | +49 40 73962 600 | +49 40 42891 2925 | fruhwald@ holz.uni-hamburg.de |
| GRANHOLM, Heikki | VTT Energy | FINLAND | |||
| HEATON, Rebecca | Cardiff University, The Salix Project | Llysdinam Field Centre, Newbridge-on-Wye, Powys LD1 6NB, UK | +44 1597 860 308 | +44 1597 860 381 | |
| HEIKINHEIMO, Pirkko | Ministry of Environment | P.O. Box 380, Kasarmikatu 25, 00131 Helsinki, FINLAND | +358 9 1991 9692 | +358 9 1991 9439 | pirkko.heikinheimo@vyh.fi |
| HOLM, Stefan | Swedish National Energy Administration, Department for Energy Policy Analysis | 63104 Eskilstuna, SWEDEN | +46 16 554 2142 | +46 16 554 2262 | Stefan.holm@stem.se |
| HYTTINEN, Pentti | European Commission, DG XII, COST Secretariat,Forest and Forestry | P.O. Box 310, 200 rue de la Loi, SDME 1/50, 1049 Brussels, BELGIUM | +32 2 299 1554 | +32 2 296 4289 | pentti.hyttinen@cec.eu.int |
| JONAS, Matthias | International Institute for Applied Systems | Schlossplatz 1, 2361 Laxenburg, AUSTRIA | +43 2236 807 430 | +43 2236 807 599 | jonas@iiasa.ac.at |
| JOOSTEN, Rainer | University of Paderborn | An der Wilhelmshoehe 44, 37671 Hoexter, GERMANY | +49 5271 687 232 | +49 5271 687 233 | Joosten@t-online.de |
| KARESSUO, Anu | Finnish Forest Industries Federation | P.O.Box 336, 00171 Helsinki, FINLAND | +358 9 132 6632 | +358 9 132 4445 | anu.karessuo@ forestindustries.fi |
| KARJALAINEN, Timo | European Forest Institute | Torikatu 34, 80100 Joensuu, FINLAND | +358 13 252 0240 | +358 13 124 393 | timo.karjalainen@efi.fi |
| KÄRKKÄINEN, Leena | Finnish Forest Research Institute | Yliopistonkatu 7, 80101 Joensuu, FINLAND | +358 13 251 4145 | +358 13 251 4111 | leena.karkkainen@metla.fi |
| KARLSSON, Asa | Environmental and energy systems studies, Lund University | Gerdagatan 13, SE-223 62 Lund, SWEDEN | +46 46 222 4833 | +46 46 222 8644 | asa.karlsson@miljo.lth.se |
| KJØNAAS, O. Janne | NISK | Høyskoleveien 12, 1432 Ås, NORWAY | +47 649 49000 | +47 649 42980 | janne.kjonaas@nisk.no |
| KLÖHN, Susanne | European Forest Institute | Torikatu 34, 80100 Joensuu, FINLAND | +358 13 252 020 | +358 13 124 397 | susanne.klohn@efi.fi |
| KOLSHUS, Hans | CICERO Center for Int. Climate and Envir. Res. – Oslo | P.O.Box 1129 Blindern, 0318 Oslo, NORWAY | +47 228 58758 | +47 228 58751 | hako@cicero.uio.no |
| LAITAT, Eric | University of Gembloux, Faculty of Agriculture | Passage des Déportés 2, 5030 Gembloux, BELGIUM | +32 81 622 464 | +32 81 614 120 | becocraft@fsagx.ac.be |
| LAMPINEN, Ari | University of Jyväskylä, Environmental Sciences | P.O.Box 35, 40351 Jyväskylä, FINLAND | ala@cc.jyu.fi | ||
| LAPVETELÄINEN, Tuija | European Forest Institute | Torikatu 34, 80100 Joensuu, FINLAND | +258 13 2520236 | +358 13 124393 | tuija.lapvetelainen@efi.fi |
| LINDNER, Marcus | Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research | P.O. Box 601203, GERMANY | +49 331 288 2677 | +49 331 288 2600 | lindner@pik-potsdam.de |
| LINDER, Sune | SLU-Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Dept. of Ecology and Environmental Sciences | P.O. Box 7072, 750 07 Uppsala, SWEDEN | +46 18 672 440 | +46 18 673 376 | sune.linder@spek.slu.se |
| LOUSTAU, Denis | Institut National de la Recherche Agronomique | 69 Route d’Arcachon, PB45, 33611 Cestas, FRANCE | +33 557 979 037 | +33 556 680 546 | loustau@pierroton.inra.fr |
| MÄKIPÄÄ, Raisa | Finnish Forest Research Institute | Unioninkatu 40 A, 00170 Helsinki, FINLAND | +358 9 8570 5717 | +358 9 8570 5654 | raisa.makipaa@metla.fi |
| MANN, Margaret K. | National Renewable Energy Laboratory | 1617 Cole Blvd: MS-1613, Golden, CO 80401 USA | +1 303 275 2921 | +1 303 275 2905 | margaret_mann@nrel.gov |
| MARLAND, Gregg | Environmental Sciences Division, Oak Ridge National Laboratory | P.O. Box 2008, MS-6335 /Bethel Valley Rd., Oak Ridge TN 37831-6335 USA | +1 865 241 4850 | +1 865 574 2232 | gum@ornl.gov |
| MARTIN, Peter | Cranfield University, Silsoe, Institute for Water and Environment | Bedford MK45 4DT, U.K. | +44 1525 863 156 | +44 1525 863 344 | p.j.martin@cranfield.ac.uk |
| MASERA, Omar | UNAM, Inst. of Ecology, Campus Morelia | A.P. 27-3 (Xangari), 5809 Morelia, Michoacán, MEXICO | +52 43 208 030 | +52 5 622 3998 | omasera@ jupiter.ccu.umich.mx |
| MATALA, Juho | University of Joensuu | P.O.Box 111, 80101 Joensuu, FINLAND | +358 13 251 5320 | juho.matala@joensuu.fi | |
| MATTHEWS, Robert | Forestry Commission, Forestry Commission Research Station | Alice Holt Research Station, Wrecclesham, Farnham, Surrey GU10 4LH, U.K. | +44 1420 526 235 | +44 1420 234 50 | robert.matthews@ forestry.gsi.gov.uk |
| MILNE, Ronnie | Centre for Ecology and Hydrology, Edinburgh | Bush Estate, Penicuik EH26 0QB, U.K. | +44 131 445 4343 | +44 131 445 3943 | r.milne@ceh.ac.uk |
| NABUURS, Gert-Jan | ALTERRA, Green World Research | P.O. Box 47, 6700 AA Wageningen, THE NETHERLANDS | +31 317 477 897 | +31 317 424 988 | g.j.nabuurs@ibn.dlo.nl |
| PALOSUO, Taru | VTT Energy | P.O.Box 1606, 02150 Espoo, FINLAND | +358 9 456 5764 | +358 9 456 6538 | Taru.Palosuo@vtt.fi |
| PERKS, Michael | University College Dublin, Belfield Campus | D4 Dublin, IRELAND | +353 1 706 2251 | +353 1 706 1153 | Michael.Perks@ucd.ie |
| PETERSEN, Ann Kristin | Agricultural University of Norway, Department of Forest Sciences | P.O.Box 5044, 1432 Aas, NORWAY | +47 64 94 8965 | +47 64 94 8890 | ann-kristin.petersen@ isf.nlh.no |
| PETTERSSON, Magnus | Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Dept. of Silviculture | 90183 Umeå, SWEDEN | +46 90 786 6954 | +46 90 786 6954 | Magnus.Pettersson@ ssko.slu.se |
| PIGNARD, Gérôme | Inventaire Forestier National/CER, Cellule de la Ressource | Place des Arcades Maurin, 34971 Lattes, FRANCE | +33 4 6707 8084 | +33 4 6707 8091 | gpignard@ifn.fr |
| PILEGAARD, Kim | Risø National Laboratory | P.O.Box 49, 4000 Roskilde, DENMARK | +45 4677 4175 | +45 4677 4160 | kim.pilegaard@risoe.dk |
| PINGOUD Kim | VTT Energy | P.O.Box 1606, 02044 VTT, FINLAND | +358 9 456 5074 | +358 9 456 6538 | kim.pingoud@vtt.fi |
| POHJOLA, Johanna | Finnish Forest Research Institute | Unioninkatu 40 A, 00170 Helsinki, FINLAND | +358 9 857 05738 | +358 9 857 05717 | johanna.pohjola@metla.fi |
| PUSSINEN, Ari | European Forest Institute | Torikatu 34, FIN-80100 Joensuu, FINLAND | +358 13 252 0241 | +358 13 124 393 | ari.pussinen@efi.fi |
| RADOGLOU, Kalliopi | Forest Research Institute | Vassilika, 57006 Thessaloniki, GREECE | +30 31 461 171 | +30 31 929 806 | radoglou@fri.gr |
| RAFTOYANNIS, Yannis | Forest Research Institute | Vasilika, 57006 Thessaloniki, GREECE | +30 31 461 172 | +30 31 461 341 | rafto@fri.gr |
| RISBERG, Sven | Swedish National Energy Administration | Kungsgatan 43, 63104 Eskilstuna, SWEDEN | +46 16 544 2116 | +46 16 544 2261 | sven.risberg@stem.se |
| ROBERTSON, Kimberly | Joanneum Research and Forest Research (NZ) | Elisabethstrasse 5, 8010-Graz, AUSTRIA | +43 316 876 1330 | +43 316 876 1320 | kimberly.robertson@ joanneum.at |
| ROBLEDO, Carmenza | EMPA-Swiss Federal Laboratory for Materials Testing and Research | Ueberlandestrasse 129, 8600 Duebendorf, SWITZERLAND | +41 1 823 4321 | +41 1 823 4007 | carmenza.robledo@empa.ch |
| SABATÉ, Santi | CREAF, Autonomous University of Barcelona | 08193 Bellaterra, Spain | +34 93 5811 920 | +34 93 5811 312 | santi.sabate@blues.uab.es |
| SAVIN, Igor | Petrozavodsk State University | 33 Lenin, 185640 Petrozavodsk, RUSSIA | +7 8142 71 10 56 | +7 8142 71 10 00 | savin@mainpgu.karelia.ru |
| SAVOLAINEN, Ilkka | Technical Research Centre of Finland | P.O. Box 1606, 02044 VTT, FINLAND | +358 40 595 0325 | +358 9 456 6538 | ilkka.savolainen@vtt.fi |
| SCHARAI-RAD, Mohammad | University of Hamburg, Dept. of Wood Technology | Leuschnerstrasse 91, 21031 Hamburg, GERMANY | +49 40 739 62617 | +49 40 428 912 925 | scharad@ holz.uni-hamburg.de |
| SCHLAMADINGER, Bernhard | JOANNEUM RESEARCH | Elisabethstrasse 5, 8010-Graz, AUSTRIA | +43 316 876 1340 | +43 316 876 1320 | bernhard.schlamadinger@ joanneum.at |
| SCHULTE, Andreas | University of Paderborn, Institute of Forest Ecology and Soil Science | An der Wilhelmshöhe 44, 37671 Höxter, GERMANY | +49 5541 34579 | +49 5541 34581 | schulte@ energieholz-kongress.de |
| SEUFERT, Günther | European Commission, Joint Research Centre | Via E. Fermi, 1, 21020 Ispra (VA), ITALY | +39 033 278 5784 | +39 033 278 5022 | guenther.seufert@jrc.it |
| SIEVÄNEN, Risto | Finnish Forest Research Institute, Vantaa Research Centre | P.O. Box 18, 01301 Vantaa, FINLAND | +358 9 8570 5373 | +358 9 8570 5361 | risto.sievanen@metla.fi |
| SIGURDSSON, Bjarni D. | SLU – Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Dept. for Production Ecology | P.O.Box 7042, 75007 Uppsala, SWEDEN | +46 18 672 562 | +46 18 673 376 | Bjarni.Sigurdsson@ spek.slu.se |
| SNORRASON, Arnor | Icelandic Forest Research | Mogilsa, 116 Reykjavik, ICELAND | +354 515 4508 | +354 515 4501 | arnorrsr@simnet.is |
| SOMOGYI, Zoltán | Forest Research Institute, Department of Silviculture and Yield | Frankel Leó U. 42-44, H – 1277 Budapest, Pf. 17, HUNGARY | +36 1 326 1769 | +36 1 326 1639 | h9013som@ella.hu |
| SPITZER, Josef | Joanneum Research | Elisabethstrasse 5, A-8010 Graz, AUSTRIA | +43 316 876 1332 | +43 316 876 1320 | josef.spitzer@ joanneum.at |
| STOLP, Johan | SBH-Institute for Forest and Forest Products | Bosrandweg 5 / P.O. Box 253, 6700 AG Wageningen, THE NETHERLANDS | +31 317 466 560 | +31 317 410 247 | johan.stolp@sbh.nl |
| SUBAK, Susan | U.S. Environmental Protection Agency | 1200 Pennsylvania Ave. N.W., 20460 Washington DC, USA | +1 202 260 7020 | subak.susan@epa.gov | |
| TEMMERMAN, Michaël | CRAGx, Biomass Section | Chaussée de Namur 146, 5030 Gembloux, BELGIUM | +32 81 61 25 01 | +32 81 61 58 47 | temmerman@cragx.fgov.be |
| TOIVONEN, Ritva | PTT | Eerikinkatu 28 A, 00180 Helsinki, FINLAND | +358 9 3488 8412 | +358 9 3488 8500 | ritva.toivonen@ptt.fi |
| TROSSERO, Miguel A. | FAO, Wood Energy Programme, Forest Products Division, Forestry Department | Viale delle Terme di Caracalla, 00100 Rome, ITALY | +39 06 5225 4175 | +39 06 5225 5618 | miguel.trossero@fao.org |
| VESTERDAL, Lars | Danish Centre for Forest, Landscape and Planning | Hoersholm Kongevej 11, 2970 Hoersholm, DENMARK | +45 45 17 8336 | +45 45 76 3233 | lav@fsl.dk |
| VILLA, Aki | University of Joensuu, Faculty of Forestry | P.O. Box 111, 80101 Joensuu, FINLAND | +358 13 251 3637 | +358 13 251 3590 | aki.villa@joensuu.fi |
| WEISS, Peter | Federal Environment Agency | Spitterlauerlaende 5, 1090 Wien, AUSTRIA | +43 1 31304 3440 | +43 1 31304 5400 | weissp@ubavie.gv.at |
| WIHERSAARI, Margareta | VTT Energy | P.O.Box 1606, 02044 VTT, FINLAND | +358 9 456 5808 | +358 9 456 6538 | margareta.wihersaari@vtt.fi |
| YILDIZ, Niyazi | Poplar Institute | P.O.Box 93, 41001 Izmir, TURKEY | +90 262 335 0885 | +90 262 349 5497 | kavak@ttnet.net.tr |